Crossref journal-article
American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS)
Science (221)
Abstract

The binding of dioxygen and carbon monoxide to heme proteins such as myoglobin and hemoglobin has been studied with flash photolysis. At temperatures below 200 K, binding occurs from within the heme pocket and, contrary to expectation, with nearly equal rates for both ligands. This observation has led to a reexamination of the theory of the association reaction taking into account friction, protein structure, and the nature of electronic transitions. The rate coefficients for the limiting cases of large and small friction are found with simple arguments that use characteristic lengths and times. The arguments indicate how transition state theory as well as calculations based on nonadiabatic perturbation theory, which is called the Golden Rule, may fail. For ligand-binding reactions the data suggest the existence of intermediate states not directly observed so far. The general considerations may also apply to other biomolecular processes such as electron transport.

Bibliography

Frauenfelder, H., & Wolynes, P. G. (1985). Rate Theories and Puzzles of Hemeprotein Kinetics. Science, 229(4711), 337–345.

Authors 2
  1. Hans Frauenfelder (first)
  2. Peter G. Wolynes (additional)
References 82 Referenced 420
  1. Alben, J. O., Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 79: 3744 (1982). / Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America (1982)
  2. ALBEN, J.O., ISOTOPE EFFECT IN MOLECULAR TUNNELING, PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 44: 1157 (1980). (10.1103/PhysRevLett.44.1157) / PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS (1980)
  3. ALBERDING, N, BINDING OF CARBON-MONOXIDE TO ISOLATED HEMOGLOBIN CHAINS, BIOCHEMISTRY 17: 43 (1978). (10.1021/bi00594a007) / BIOCHEMISTRY (1978)
  4. ALBERDING, N, TUNNELING IN LIGAND-BINDING TO HEME PROTEINS, SCIENCE 192: 1002 (1976). (10.1126/science.1273579) / SCIENCE (1976)
  5. ALBERDING N.A. THESIS U ILLINOIS UR (1978).
  6. ALI, D.P., EFFECT OF ELECTRONIC-TRANSITION DYNAMICS ON IODINE ATOM RECOMBINATION IN LIQUIDS, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 78: 6640 (1983). (10.1063/1.444662) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1983)
  7. AUSTIN, R.H., DYNAMICS OF LIGAND-BINDING TO MYOGLOBIN, BIOCHEMISTRY 14: 5355 (1975). (10.1021/bi00695a021) / BIOCHEMISTRY (1975)
  8. BEECE, D, SOLVENT VISCOSITY AND PROTEIN DYNAMICS, BIOCHEMISTRY 19: 5147 (1980). (10.1021/bi00564a001) / BIOCHEMISTRY (1980)
  9. BEECE, D, THE EFFECT OF VISCOSITY ON THE PHOTOCYCLE OF BACTERIORHODOPSIN, PHOTOCHEMISTRY AND PHOTOBIOLOGY 33: 517 (1981). (10.1111/j.1751-1097.1981.tb05454.x) / PHOTOCHEMISTRY AND PHOTOBIOLOGY (1981)
  10. BLOMBERG, C, BROWNIAN-MOTION THEORY OF CHEMICAL TRANSITION RATES, PHYSICA A 86: 49 (1977). (10.1016/0378-4371(77)90061-9) / PHYSICA A (1977)
  11. BRINKMAN, H.C., BROWNIAN MOTION IN A FIELD OF FORCE AND THE DIFFUSION THEORY OF CHEMICAL REACTIONS .2., PHYSICA 22: 149 (1956). (10.1016/S0031-8914(56)80019-0) / PHYSICA (1956)
  12. BUTTIKER, M, THERMAL-ACTIVATION IN EXTREMELY UNDERDAMPED JOSEPHSON-JUNCTION CIRCUITS, PHYSICAL REVIEW B 28: 1268 (1983). (10.1103/PhysRevB.28.1268) / PHYSICAL REVIEW B (1983)
  13. BUTTIKER, M, THERMALLY ACTIVATED ESCAPE FROM UNDERDAMPED METASTABLE WELLS, PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 52: 1250 (1984). (10.1103/PhysRevLett.52.1250) / PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS (1984)
  14. CALDIN, E.F., DIFFUSION-CONTROLLED KINETICS IN REACTION OF FERROPROTOPORPHYRIN-IX WITH CARBON-MONOXIDE - REACTION STUDIES AS A FUNCTION OF PRESSURE, TEMPERATURE AND SOLVENT BY MEANS OF A LASER FLASH-PHOTOLYSIS HIGH-PRESSURE APPARATUS, JOURNAL OF THE CHEMICAL SOCIETY-FARADAY TRANSACTIONS I 71: 515 (1975). / JOURNAL OF THE CHEMICAL SOCIETY-FARADAY TRANSACTIONS I (1975)
  15. CARMELI, B, NON-MARKOVIAN THEORY OF ACTIVATED RATE-PROCESSES .1. FORMALISM, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 79: 393 (1983). (10.1063/1.445535) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1983)
  16. CARMELI, B, NON-MARKOVIAN THEORY OF ACTIVATED RATE-PROCESSES .3. BRIDGING BETWEEN THE KRAMERS LIMITS, PHYSICAL REVIEW A 29: 1481 (1984). (10.1103/PhysRevA.29.1481) / PHYSICAL REVIEW A (1984)
  17. CARMELI, B, THERMALLY ACTIVATED ESCAPE FROM UNDERDAMPED METASTABLE WELLS - REPLY, PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 52: 1251 (1984). (10.1103/PhysRevLett.52.1251) / PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS (1984)
  18. CHANCE B TUNNELING BIOL SYSTE (1979).
  19. COLLMAN, J.P., OXYGEN BINDING TO IRON PORPHYRINS, JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY 97: 7185 (1975). (10.1021/ja00857a050) / JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY (1975)
  20. 10.1017/S003358350000175X
  21. DICKERSON R.E. HEMOGLOBIN STRUCTURE (1983).
  22. DLOTT, D.D., NANOSECOND FLASH-PHOTOLYSIS STUDY OF CARBON-MONOXIDE BINDING TO THE BETA-CHAIN OF HEMOGLOBIN ZURICH [BETA-63(E7)HIS-]ARG], PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES 80: 6239 (1983). / PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (1983)
  23. DOSTER, W, CONTROL AND PH-DEPENDENCE OF LIGAND-BINDING TO HEME-PROTEINS, BIOCHEMISTRY 21: 4831 (1982). (10.1021/bi00263a001) / BIOCHEMISTRY (1982)
  24. EINSTEIN, A, The theory of the Brownian Motion, ANNALEN DER PHYSIK 19: 371 (1906). / ANNALEN DER PHYSIK (1906)
  25. 10.1038/280558a0
  26. FRAUENFELDER, H, STRUCTURE DYNAMICS I: 227 (1983). / STRUCTURE DYNAMICS I (1983)
  27. FRAUENFELDER, H, STRUCTURE MOTION MEM: 205 (1985). / STRUCTURE MOTION MEM (1985)
  28. FRIEDMAN, H.L., THEORY OF FE-2+-FE-3+ ELECTRON EXCHANGE IN WATER, FARADAY DISCUSSIONS 74: 73 (1982). (10.1039/DC9827400073) / FARADAY DISCUSSIONS (1982)
  29. FRIEDMAN, J.M., THE IRON-PROXIMAL HISTIDINE LINKAGE AND PROTEIN CONTROL OF OXYGEN BINDING IN HEMOGLOBIN - A TRANSIENT RAMAN-STUDY, JOURNAL OF BIOLOGICAL CHEMISTRY 258: 10564 (1983). (10.1016/S0021-9258(17)44493-0) / JOURNAL OF BIOLOGICAL CHEMISTRY (1983)
  30. 10.1021/bi00574a023
  31. Glasstone S. The Theory of Rate Processes (1941).
  32. Goddard, W. A., Quantum Chemistry in Biomedical Sciences: 419 (1981). / Quantum Chemistry in Biomedical Sciences (1981)
  33. GOLDSTEIN, R.D., SWANN SONG FOR REMEDIES - EQUITABLE RELIEF IN BURGER COURT, HARVARD CIVIL RIGHTS-CIVIL LIBERTIES LAW REVIEW 13: 1 (1978). / HARVARD CIVIL RIGHTS-CIVIL LIBERTIES LAW REVIEW (1978)
  34. GROTE, R.F., REACTIVE MODES IN CONDENSED PHASE REACTIONS, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 74: 4465 (1981). (10.1063/1.441634) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1981)
  35. GROTE, R.F., SADDLE-POINT MODEL FOR ATOM TRANSFER-REACTIONS IN SOLUTION, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 75: 2191 (1981). (10.1063/1.442331) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1981)
  36. GROTE, R.F., J CHEM PHYS 76: 2715 (1981). / J CHEM PHYS (1981)
  37. GROTE, R.F., ENERGY DIFFUSION-CONTROLLED REACTIONS IN SOLUTION, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 77: 3736 (1982). (10.1063/1.444277) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1982)
  38. HANGGI, P, PHYSICS OF LIGAND MIGRATION IN BIOMOLECULES, JOURNAL OF STATISTICAL PHYSICS 30: 401 (1983). (10.1007/BF01012314) / JOURNAL OF STATISTICAL PHYSICS (1983)
  39. HANGGI, P, STOCHASTIC-PROCESSES - TIME EVOLUTION, SYMMETRIES AND LINEAR RESPONSE, PHYSICS REPORTS-REVIEW SECTION OF PHYSICS LETTERS 88: 207 (1982). / PHYSICS REPORTS-REVIEW SECTION OF PHYSICS LETTERS (1982)
  40. HANGGI, P, THERMALLY ACTIVATED ESCAPE RATE IN PRESENCE OF LONG-TIME MEMORY, PHYSICAL REVIEW A 26: 1168 (1982). (10.1103/PhysRevA.26.1168) / PHYSICAL REVIEW A (1982)
  41. HASHA, D.L., HIGH-PRESSURE NMR-STUDY OF DYNAMICAL EFFECTS ON CONFORMATIONAL ISOMERIZATION OF CYCLOHEXANE, JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY 104: 2290 (1982). (10.1021/ja00372a029) / JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY (1982)
  42. HASHA, D.L., J CHEM PHYS 75: 1570 (1981). (10.1063/1.442192) / J CHEM PHYS (1981)
  43. HASINOFF, B.B., KINETIC ACTIVATION VOLUMES OF BINDING OF OXYGEN AND CARBON-MONOXIDE TO HEMOGLOBIN AND MYOGLOBIN STUDIED ON A HIGH-PRESSURE LASER FLASH-PHOTOLYSIS APPARATUS, BIOCHEMISTRY 13: 3111 (1974). (10.1021/bi00712a017) / BIOCHEMISTRY (1974)
  44. HELFAND, E, THEORY OF KINETICS OF CONFORMATIONAL TRANSITIONS IN POLYMERS, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 54: 4651 (1971). (10.1063/1.1674737) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1971)
  45. HELLER, E.J., RADIATIONLESS TRANSITIONS IN A NEW LIGHT, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 79: 3336 (1983). (10.1063/1.446235) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1983)
  46. JORTNER, J, DYNAMICS OF NON-ADIABATIC ATOM TRANSFER IN BIOLOGICAL-SYSTEMS - CARBON-MONOXIDE BINDING TO HEMOGLOBIN, JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY 101: 3744 (1979). (10.1021/ja00508a007) / JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY (1979)
  47. Kauzmann W. Quantum Chemistry (1957).
  48. KEERY, K.M., INFLUENCE OF SOLVENT ON PHOTOCHEMICAL ISOMERIZATION - PHOTOPHYSICS OF DIPHENYL BUTADIENE IN POLAR-SOLVENTS, CHEMICAL PHYSICS LETTERS 93: 322 (1982). (10.1016/0009-2614(82)83701-9) / CHEMICAL PHYSICS LETTERS (1982)
  49. KNAPP, E.W., THE INFLUENCE OF PROTEIN DYNAMICS ON MOSSBAUER-SPECTRA, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 78: 4701 (1983). (10.1063/1.445316) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1983)
  50. KRAMERS, H.A., Brownian motion in a field of force and the diffusion model of chemical reactions, PHYSICA 7: 284 (1940). (10.1016/S0031-8914(40)90098-2) / PHYSICA (1940)
  51. KUBO, R, FLUCTUATION-DISSIPATION THEOREM, REPORTS ON PROGRESS IN PHYSICS 29: 255 (1966). (10.1088/0034-4885/29/1/306) / REPORTS ON PROGRESS IN PHYSICS (1966)
  52. LANDAU, L, PHYSIKALISCHE ZEITSCHRIFT DER SOWJETUNION 1: 89 (1932). / PHYSIKALISCHE ZEITSCHRIFT DER SOWJETUNION (1932)
  53. LANDAU, L, ZEITSCHFRIFT FUR PHYSIK (SOWJETUNION) 2: 1932 (1932). / ZEITSCHFRIFT FUR PHYSIK (SOWJETUNION) (1932)
  54. Landau, L. D., Quantum Mechanics: 304 (1958). / Quantum Mechanics (1958)
  55. LANDAUER, R, FREQUENCY FACTORS IN THERMALLY ACTIVATED PROCESS, PHYSICAL REVIEW 121: 1668 (1961). (10.1103/PhysRev.121.1668) / PHYSICAL REVIEW (1961)
  56. LANGER, J.S., THEORY OF NUCLEATION RATES, PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 21: 973 (1968). (10.1103/PhysRevLett.21.973) / PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS (1968)
  57. Lever A. B. P. Iron Porphyrins (1983).
  58. MacQuarrie D. A. Statistical Mechanics (1976).
  59. MASHIMO, S, DIELECTRIC STUDY OF CHAIN MOTION OF POLY(PARA-CHLOROSTYRENE) IN DILUTE-SOLUTION, MACROMOLECULES 9: 91 (1976). (10.1021/ma60049a018) / MACROMOLECULES (1976)
  60. MCCAMMON, J.A., SIMULATION OF PROTEIN DYNAMICS, ANNUAL REVIEW OF PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY 31: 29 (1980). (10.1146/annurev.pc.31.100180.000333) / ANNUAL REVIEW OF PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY (1980)
  61. 10.1021/bi00573a001
  62. MOELWYNHUGHES, E.A., PHYSICAL CHEM: 431 (1961). / PHYSICAL CHEM (1961)
  63. MONTGOMERY, J.R., J CHEM PHYS 70: 4065 (1979). / J CHEM PHYS (1979)
  64. NADLER, W, GENERALIZED MOMENT EXPANSION FOR THE MOSSBAUER SPECTRUM OF BROWNIAN PARTICLES, PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS 51: 1712 (1983). (10.1103/PhysRevLett.51.1712) / PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS (1983)
  65. PARAK, F, PROTEIN DYNAMICS - MOSSBAUER-SPECTROSCOPY ON DEOXYMYOGLOBIN CRYSTALS, JOURNAL OF MOLECULAR BIOLOGY 161: 177 (1982). (10.1016/0022-2836(82)90285-6) / JOURNAL OF MOLECULAR BIOLOGY (1982)
  66. REDI, M.H., HEMOGLOBIN CARBON-MONOXIDE BINDING RATE - LOW-TEMPERATURE MAGNETO-OPTICAL DETECTION OF SPIN-TUNNELING, BIOPHYSICAL JOURNAL 35: 471 (1981). (10.1016/S0006-3495(81)84803-5) / BIOPHYSICAL JOURNAL (1981)
  67. ROTHENBERGER, G, SOLVENT INFLUENCE ON PHOTO-ISOMERIZATION DYNAMICS, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 79: 5360 (1983). (10.1063/1.445699) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1983)
  68. SKINNER, J.L., RELAXATION PROCESSES AND CHEMICAL-KINETICS, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 69: 2143 (1978). (10.1063/1.436814) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1978)
  69. SORENSEN L.B. THESIS U ILLINOIS UR (1980).
  70. STUECKELBERG, ECG, HELVETICA PHYSICA ACTA 5: 369 (1932). / HELVETICA PHYSICA ACTA (1932)
  71. SUTIN, N, NUCLEAR, ELECTRONIC, AND FREQUENCY FACTORS IN ELECTRON-TRANSFER REACTIONS, ACCOUNTS OF CHEMICAL RESEARCH 15: 275 (1982). (10.1021/ar00081a002) / ACCOUNTS OF CHEMICAL RESEARCH (1982)
  72. TEMBE, B.L., THE THEORY OF THE FE2+-FE3+ ELECTRON EXCHANGE IN WATER, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 76: 1490 (1982). (10.1063/1.443110) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1982)
  73. TRUHLAR, D.G., CURRENT STATUS OF TRANSITION-STATE THEORY, JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY 87: 2664 (1983). (10.1021/j100238a003) / JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY (1983)
  74. TULLY, J.C., J CHEM PHYS 55: 262 (1971). / J CHEM PHYS (1971)
  75. ULSTRUP J CHARGE TRANSFER PROC (1979).
  76. VANKAMPEN, N.G., SOLUBLE MODEL FOR DIFFUSION IN A BISTABLE POTENTIAL, JOURNAL OF STATISTICAL PHYSICS 17: 71 (1977). (10.1007/BF01268919) / JOURNAL OF STATISTICAL PHYSICS (1977)
  77. VELSKO, S.P., SOLVENT INFLUENCE ON PHOTOCHEMICAL ISOMERIZATIONS - PHOTOPHYSICS OF DODCI, CHEMICAL PHYSICS 65: 59 (1982). (10.1016/0301-0104(82)85055-6) / CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1982)
  78. VELSKO, S.P., BREAKDOWN OF KRAMER THEORY DESCRIPTION OF PHOTOCHEMICAL ISOMERIZATION AND THE POSSIBLE INVOLVEMENT OF FREQUENCY-DEPENDENT FRICTION, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 78: 249 (1983). (10.1063/1.444549) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1983)
  79. WARSHEL, A, DYNAMICS OF REACTIONS IN POLAR-SOLVENTS - SEMI-CLASSICAL TRAJECTORY STUDIES OF ELECTRON-TRANSFER AND PROTON-TRANSFER REACTIONS, JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY 86: 2218 (1982). (10.1021/j100209a016) / JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY (1982)
  80. WIDOM, B, REACTION KINETICS IN STOCHASTIC MODELS, JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS 55: 44 (1971). (10.1063/1.1675541) / JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1971)
  81. ZENER, C, Non-adiabatic crossing of energy levels, PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY OF LONDON SERIES A-CONTAINING PAPERS OF A MATHEMATICAL AND PHYSICAL CHARACTER 137: 696 (1932). / PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY OF LONDON SERIES A-CONTAINING PAPERS OF A MATHEMATICAL AND PHYSICAL CHARACTER (1932)
  82. ZUSMAN, L.D., OUTER-SPHERE ELECTRON-TRANSFER IN POLAR-SOLVENTS, CHEMICAL PHYSICS 49: 295 (1980). (10.1016/0301-0104(80)85267-0) / CHEMICAL PHYSICS (1980)
Dates
Type When
Created 18 years, 11 months ago (Oct. 5, 2006, 3:42 p.m.)
Deposited 1 year, 7 months ago (Jan. 14, 2024, 5:13 a.m.)
Indexed 3 weeks, 4 days ago (Aug. 12, 2025, 5:49 p.m.)
Issued 40 years, 1 month ago (July 26, 1985)
Published 40 years, 1 month ago (July 26, 1985)
Published Print 40 years, 1 month ago (July 26, 1985)
Funders 0

None

@article{Frauenfelder_1985, title={Rate Theories and Puzzles of Hemeprotein Kinetics}, volume={229}, ISSN={1095-9203}, url={http://dx.doi.org/10.1126/science.4012322}, DOI={10.1126/science.4012322}, number={4711}, journal={Science}, publisher={American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS)}, author={Frauenfelder, Hans and Wolynes, Peter G.}, year={1985}, month=jul, pages={337–345} }