1. It is possible to treat the excitation of an atom by an α-particle in two ways; we may either solve the Schrödinger equation for the system consisting of the α-particle and the atom, or we may, on account of the great mass of the α-particle, treat it as a moving centre of force, and solve the Schrödinger equation for the electrons in the field of the α-particle and nucleus, If the α-particle has velocity υ greater than the orbital velocities of the electrons, it is possible to obtain approximate formulae for the excitation probabilities by both methods; in the former case by the well known Born method, and in the latter case by a method first used in this connection by Gaunt*, and which is essentially the same as the method of variation of constants. The two methods give formally very different formulae for the excitation probabilities; it is the purpose of this paper to show that they are in fact identical if the ratio of the mass of the electron to that of the α-particle be considered vanishingly small.

Frame, J. W. (1931). On the Mathematical Equivalence of two ways of regarding the Excitation of an Atom by a Fast Moving α-particle. Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, 27(4), 511–517.